Showing posts with label Catholic schools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catholic schools. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Catholic Education Ad Campaign in the Empire State Strikes Back






By Sister Mary Ann Walsh

An ad campaign in the Empire State has Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York and a handful of Catholic school kids, some wearing sweaters from St. Mark’s School in Harlem, addressing Governor Andrew Cuomo directly.

The issue? The governor’s apparent reneging on a promise to the state’s bishops to include in the state budget a tax credit to benefit all schools, Catholic and otherwise. Known as the Education Investment Tax Credit, the proposal lets people lower tax bills by donating to schools. Money to private schools could be used for scholarships for student who otherwise would find Catholic school education beyond their reach.

It is no surprise that opposition to the idea comes from public school teacher unions who tend to see any help to non-public schools as a threat to their survival. This despite the proposal’s plan to also reimburse public school teachers for out-of-pocket expenses.

A tax credit would allow donors to subtract the total amount of the donation from what they owe the state in taxes, up to a certain amount. The state would not hand over money, but citizens who want to help schools would. New Yorkers would be free to decide whether to give to public or private school coffers or to no one at all. New York State already gives tax credits to breweries and film makers. Why not to kids?

The idea has appeal. The NYS Senate passed it 55-4. Two-thirds of the NYS Assembly co-sponsored it. Similar ideas have proven successful elsewhere, for example in the states of Wisconsin, Ohio, Arizona, Florida, Pennsylvania, District of Columbia, Utah, Rhode Island, Iowa, Georgia, Louisiana, Indiana, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Colorado, Virginia, Mississippi, New Hampshire and Alabama.

Arguments in support of Catholic schools seem like no-brainers. The government requires parents to educate their children, but in doing so, it should not deny parents the freedom to choose what they deem the best school for their offspring. It even can be seen as a religious freedom issue for parents who seek holistic schooling, which includes moral, ethical and religious education.

Parents also have the right – even the duty – to do best by their child when it comes to education. Where schools are substandard, as many schools in urban areas are, parents have a right to enroll a child in an alternative school where the child feels and is safe. These are basic prerequisites for learning. With choice, parents can opt for a public school, parochial school, private school, or charter school. When it comes to something as vital as a child’s education, parents need the freedom to choose.

Even a top-flight school, public or otherwise, may not be right for some youngsters. To ask children to tough it out for several years can be cruel. Who wants to be miserable for six hours a day, five days a week, ten months annually for who knows how many years? When in a miserable work experience, adults have the option to seek other employment. Why should vulnerable children simply be stuck and expected to tough it out?

Governor Cuomo associates himself with choice in other areas; it’s puzzling that he won’t support freedom in education.






Monday, January 14, 2013

American Girl Catholic School Uniform


Catholic schools are in vogue. Proof: You can buy a Catholic school uniform for an American Girl doll. In your favorite plaid. You can find them for Barbie too. All the best dressed dolls are sporting them. They’re $25-$30 online.

            However, though the dolls are going traditional, the Catholic schools are not. Catholic Schools are in transition mode.

            National Catholic Educational Association’s latest statistics for the 2011-2012 academic year note that nationwide there are 6,841 Catholic Schools: 5,636 elementary/middle and 1,205 secondary. More than 26 percent of them, 1,822 Catholic schools, have waiting lists for admission. Total school student enrollment is 2,031,455, with 1,440,572 in elementary/middle schools and 590,883 in secondary schools. Most students are Catholic, but more than 15 percent are not.

The schools have a long history – St. Elizabeth Ann Seton, founder of the Catholic schools, opened her first school in Baltimore in 1808. Today’s schools are a far cry from then.

The need to work to attract students is one reason. Years ago Catholic schools didn’t recruit. Students came from the parish in which they were located. Now with Mass attendance down, many families don’t see the parish school and do not automatically think local Catholic school. Schools no longer expect the nearby parish to underwrite them, though some parishes do to an extent. Now Catholic schools must market – sell themselves as never before. Catholic elementary schools are adopting practices once reserved for high school and higher education. Enrollment management and advancement practices such as annual giving programs are being introduced to let schools plan and manage resources responsibly.

            Finances are but one concern, however. The more important questions address the why of Catholic education. In our pluralistic society, intentional efforts must go to creating an environment that stresses not just the three Rs plus religion, but also respect for the human person and the goal of eternity.

Religious values are real. One mother told me that a boy in her daughter’s class had cancer. He was dying and the children prayed for him every day. She liked that her child was learning to deal with one of life’s realities and to bring concerns to Jesus.

            Another mother told of her four-year-old’s experience. On the first day of pre-school he was reflective throughout lunch. Finally he confided, “You know, Mom, you can trust God.” Then he sang about trust in God, a ditty he’d just learned. The message will do him well for life.

            Today, school backers know that the common elements of a successful Catholic school include a strong Catholic identity, clear doctrinal teaching and sacramental focus, mission driven decision-making, a strong, vision-oriented administrator and faculty, active parent involvement, focused academic curriculum and an emphasis on community involvement. Soon another measure of success will be how schools provide Catholic education for the Hispanic community and otherwise support the nation’s new families and immigrants.

             Decades ago Catholic schools moved children of immigrants up the social ladder through education. The schools started as an alternative to public schools that promoted Protestantism. Today they provide a different form of alternative education, giving parents at all economic levels a choice to send their children to a school that is right for that child, academically excellent and supportive of the faith for which the school exists. 

Friday, November 30, 2012

Five Things to Remember on Nov. 30



 
1.  Sunday, the first Sunday of Advent, begins a new church year. The U.S. Conference of CatholicBishops has outdone itself with this year’s Advent resources. Among them is a downloadable family Advent calendar, in English and in Spanish. There are easy ways to make the hectic season holy.
 
2. Pope Benedict’s latest book “The Infancy Narratives—Jesus of Nazareth” is getting some negative press. Pundits like Stephen Colbert, the master of the tongue-in-cheek, are making the pope out to be a grinch for writing that the bible’s Christmas story doesn’t speak of animals at the crib and that the angels said, not sang, “Glory to God in the highest…” Reuters’ Journalist PhilPullella, however, clarifies what’s really in the book in his wire servicearticle. Hint: you can still sing carols and place replicas of dogs, camels, cows and sheep in your manger scene.
 
3. The National Religious Retirement Collection will be taken up in parishes the weekend of Dec. 8-9. If you want to know why it is important, consider the following: The U.S. Social Security system projects that it needs four wage earners for every retired beneficiary in order to keep the system solvent.  By 2022 religious institutes will have one wage earner for every four retired – the exact inverse. If you want a worthy collection, this one is it. Check out www.retiredreligious.org
 
4. When it comes to giving gifts, it is time to recognize the church’s largesse through the Catholic school system. Based on public school per pupil cost, Catholic elementary and secondary schools save the nation more than $20 billion dollars a year. Lots of info at www.ncea.org
 
5.      God loves you.

 

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Catholic schools give America more than chump change


            I’ve bought pizza, chaperoned dances, donated to appeals – all fundraisers for Catholic schools – and paid tuition. Which is why I am bent out of shape by an article on church finances in Aug. 18 issue of The Economist. The article in the magazine that defines itself as “authoritative” makes all kinds of claims without data to back them up. Most annoying is its blithe statement that local and federal government “bankroll” Catholic schools.

            The article is filled with errors, such as its guess that church giving dropped by 20 percent because of the sex abuse scandal heralded in the media in 2002 and henceforth.  Real data from the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) indicate, however, that church giving increased significantly in recent years. CARA researcher Mark Gray noted August 21 that "on average, Catholic households gave about $8 in weekly collections in 2000 and today they give about $10. Even after adjusting for the effects of inflation, annual offertory in parishes in the U.S. grew from $361,000 in 2000 to 478,000 in 2010."  Adds Gray, who spends his life crunching numbers, “there is no evidence I know of that Catholic parish weekly collections have declined.”

As another school year starts, it is time to highlight the church’s contribution to American education.

            The government has a mandate to educate youth, and some public schools in well-off suburbs perform spectacularly; in other areas, not so well. However, in meeting its obligation, the government gets huge help from the Catholic Church, to the tune of about $23 billion dollars a year. That is what the government does not have to pay because Catholic schools educate about two million U.S. students annually. Catholic schools provide a realistic choice in education. Given this $23 billion, you could argue it’s the church subsidizing the government (or “bankrolling” it, if you wish to use The Economist’s hyperbole), not vice versa.

            In many nations, the government subsidizes Catholic schools, but in the U.S., government aid to non-public schools is minimal. In fact, other than the DC Opportunity Scholarship program, which helps fewer than 2,000 students, no U.S. government programs fund non-public schools. In some school districts, government pays for textbooks and transportation, but even that aid is for students, not schools. It does not pay for heat, light, building repair or the principal’s salary, for example. In some impoverished areas, students receive remedial help, whether they go to a public school or parochial school. Again, such aid is for students, not schools. In fact, the money does not go directly to the Catholic school, but to a public school central office, earning interest for the public schools until the district meets its obligation to provide resources for needy students.

            Who benefits from the Catholic schools? The nation.

The National Catholic Education Association provides informative data, here from the 2010-2011 school year:

·       Catholic schools help more than Catholics. Non-Catholic enrollment is 15.4 percent. In the urban/inner-city, the percentage of non-Catholic students soars to 42 percent.

·       Minority enrollment is 30.2 percent.

·       The average per pupil tuition in parish elementary schools is $3,673. That is approximately 62.4 percent of actual costs per pupil of $5,367. About 93.9 percent of elementary schools provide some form of tuition assistance.

·       The mean freshman tuition in a Catholic secondary school is $8,182. That is approximately 80 percent of actual costs per pupil of $10,228. About 97 percent of secondary schools provide some form of tuition assistance.

·       An estimated 99 percent of Catholic secondary school students graduate, and 84 percent go on to college, compared to 44.1 percent of public school students.         

How do Catholic schools meet the shortfall between actual cost and what families pay? Primarily through direct subsidy from parishes, dioceses, religious orders, development programs and fund-raising activities.

            The Economist ought to be embarrassed. A little fact-checking would have gone a long way. When it comes to who is helping whom, the church’s contribution to America is worth $23 billion annually. Not exactly chump change.