Friday, January 4, 2013
Courts offer mixed rulings on HHS mandate
Friday, March 23, 2012
Health and Human Services’ Sacrosanct Mandate
The mandate, for the few who do not know it, would force employers, even religious ones, to accept contraceptives, including abortion-inducing drugs, and sterilization as part of their health coverage for employees. It offers a narrow religious exception that, among other things, defines a religious organization as one that hires primarily its co-religionists, serves primarily its co-religionists, and has as its purpose the inculcation of religion. In short, it dismisses the work of the Good Samaritan, who modeled helping another because of his or her need, not creed. The mandate seems to declare as non-religious hospitals that do not ask for a baptismal certificate in the E.R., soup kitchens that ask “Are you hungry?” instead of “Are you Catholic?”, and shelters that do not teach the Apostles’ Creed before giving a stranger a bed for the night.
This miserly definition of a religious ministry was devised by the American Civil Liberties Union for a law related to contraceptives in California, and HHS has adopted it as if it were wisdom from the Oracle of Delphi.
Until now the federal government has respected the church’s role in defining its ministries and has not tinkered with doctrine. Despite this history, however, HHS and the rest of the Administration now are digging in their heels on the neuralgic point. They stick to the ACLU definition unreasonably, even while saying it’s only for this health care regulation and won’t apply to others. They turn a blind eye on those of us who shudder at Caesar’s defining what constitutes a church ministry.
Why President Obama seems to have chosen this moment to become theologian-in-chief is a mystery. Why should Caesar weigh in on theological questions such as what ministry is religious enough? Distributing Holy Communion at the altar? Yes. Distributing bread in the soup kitchen? No. He might have to meditate on where the loaves and fishes on the hillside would fit, in this theological framework.
HHS seems to be torturing itself to facilitate ways to apply the mandate while circumventing religious freedom. On March 16, it floated some ideas to which it wants the public to respond. Here’s hoping they do.
In the past, numerous health care laws have refrained from defining how religious the objecting entity was – they simply said, for example, in the federal employees' health plan, that an insurer was exempt from the mandate if it had "a religious objection," or in that program and others, that health care providers, whether individual or institutional, didn't have to take part if that would violate their "religious beliefs or moral convictions." The emphasis was on the nature of the objection, rather than on what kind of other ministries the entity engages in to make it "religious."
Perhaps it is time to de-sanctify the ACLU definition of religious ministry and find an approach with which the country can live peacefully. The Administration, HHS, and the bishops, as well as the hungry, the hospitalized and the homeless, would sleep better for it.
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Seis cosas más que todos debemos saber sobre el mandato del departamento de salud y servicios humanos (HHS)
1. La disposición que ha creado tanto alboroto no ha cambiado para nada las cosas, sino que todo ha terminado como estaba. En la noche del viernes, después de todo un día anunciando cambios significativos a este mandato, el departamento de HHS emitió una regulación “sin cambios”, terminando así los trámites de esta disposición emitida originalmente en agosto del 2011. De esta forma, los empleadores religiosos dedicados a servir a fieles de otras denominaciones, todavía no están exentos como “empleadores religiosos.” De hecho, la disposición los describe como empleadores “no exentos”.
2. La disposición deja abierta la posibilidad de que hasta los “empleadores religiosos” exentos están obligados a cubrir la esterilización. En sus comentarios de agosto del 2011, la Conferencia de Obispos Católicos de los Estados Unidos advirtió que la limitada disposición de exención a “empleadores religiosos” no parecía proveer ningún alivio al mandato de esterilización—solo a la disposición de la anticoncepción—y la Conferencia específicamente pidió una clarificación. (También señalamos que el mandato cobertura obligatoria de la esterilización existe solamente en un estado: Vermont). Pero HHS no ofreció una clarificación, así que el riesgo continúa bajo la disposición final ya que ésta no ha sido cambiada.
3. La nueva “concesión” no es una regulación, sino una promesa que queda pendiente para más adelante, pasado el tiempo de pedir responsabilidades públicamente ante los electores. El viernes en la noche HHS también emitió regulaciones en las que describía su intención a desarrollar más regulaciones que pudieran aplicar la misma disposición pero de forma diferente y dirigidas a “las organizaciones religiosas no exentas y sin fines de lucro” —como son las agencias de caridad, escuelas y hospitales que aún permanecen fuera de la definición de “empleador religioso” y por tanto no están exentas. Estas disposiciones serán ejecutadas un año más tarde de que entren en vigor, por lo que si las disposiciones no dan buenos resultados, su impacto no se sentirá hasta agosto del 2013, mucho después de las elecciones presidenciales.
4. Aun cuando todas las promesas de un “arreglo” se realicen en su totalidad, los grupos religiosos de caridades, escuelas y hospitales estarán forzados a violar sus creencias. Si un empleado de estas instituciones religiosas “de segunda clase” desea cobertura de anticonceptivos o esterilización, el empleador que está opuesto a esto estará obligado a pagarlo como parte del plan de seguros del empleador. No se le podrá cargar un costo adicional a ese empleado, y esa cobertura no podrá estar comprendida en una póliza aparte. Por lo tanto, en un proceso de eliminación, los fondos de donde se pagará esta cobertura todavía deberán venir de las primas que paguen el empleador y sus empleados, aún de los que en conciencia se opongan a ello.
5. La promesa de “concesiones” ni siquiera trata de ofrecer apoyo a aquellos aseguradores que presenten una objeción de conciencia, a los empleadores religiosos con fines de lucro, a los empleadores laicos, o a personas individuales. En sus comentarios de agosto del 2011, y muchas veces después, la Conferencia de Obispos Católicos de los Estados Unidos identificó a todos los que están involucrados en este proceso, cuya libertad religiosa está siendo amenazada—que son todos los empleadores, los aseguradores y las personas individuales, y no sólo los empleadores religiosos. Los sucesos del viernes enfatizan que todos los aseguradores, incluyendo los que aseguran por su cuenta, deben proveer esta cobertura a cualquier empleado que lo desee. Por otro lado, todas las personas que pagan sus primas de seguro, no tienen otra opción que la de subsidiar esa cobertura. Sólo los empleadores que son entidades religiosas y a la vez no-lucrativas, podrán calificar para este “arreglo”.
6. Cuidado con las afirmaciones, especialmente las partidistas, de que los obispos son partidistas. Los obispos y su personal leen las regulaciones antes de evaluarlas. Los obispos no buscaron esta disputa en un año de elecciones—otros lo hicieron. Los obispos forman sus posiciones basándose en principios—en este caso, la libertad religiosa para todos, la vida y la dignidad de todo ser humano—y no las urnas, las personalidades o los partidos políticos. Los obispos tienen el deber de proclamar estos principios en todo momento, esté o no de moda hacerlo.
Aquí podrá encontrar las primeras seis observaciones de la Conferencia de Obispos Católicos de Estados Unidos referentes al mandato de HHS.
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Referral is Not the Answer, Rescinding the Mandate Is
Two short weeks ago, on January 20, the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced that virtually all health plans provided by virtually all employers, including those affiliated with the Catholic Church, would now be forced to cover sterilization procedures, abortion inducing drugs, and contraception. Under the Obama Administration’s unprecedented rule, the federal government would force the Church to include these illicit “services” in many of its insurance plans and help cover their cost.
The immediate, popular uproar against this unacceptable infringement by the federal government on religious liberty is absolutely appropriate. For two thousand years, the Church has consistently taught that abortion and contraception are wrongs that strike right at the dignity of the human person. This is not a matter of the mere opinion of a few bishops or theologians. Now, the federal government would force the Church to negotiate with insurance companies for this coverage, to purchase it and pay for actions it considers immoral. The question is not whether or not all Americans agree with the Church’s teaching on these matters. The real question is whether or not the Church—as well as other religious bodies—should have the freedom to proclaim her teaching and to practice it in a nation founded on the right to religious liberty.
In the few days since the release of the HHS rule, protests against the Administration’s infringement on religious liberty have united people of all faiths and people of good will across America. The impact is real. So now there are rumors of a possible “compromise.” If the name of the compromise is referral, it may run something like this: “We won’t make you include these services in your health plans, and you might not even have to pay for them. All you have to do is tell folks where they can go to get them. Just refer them to a local provider, and that should do it.”
Hawaii is used as an example.
In that state, employers are mandated to cover contraception (though not sterilization), and there is a slightly broader religious exemption, but it also imposes certain requirements on those who would claim the exemption: they must provide written notification to employees of other ways they can directly access coverage for, or obtain, such procedures “in an expeditious manner.”
If such a solution were proposed, it would not address the basic problem-- that of the law forcing religious entities into actions they consider immoral. The Church cannot, even reluctantly, provide information, make arrangements for, facilitate, counsel or instruct people on how to obtain these immoral procedures. To do so would be to participate in the violation of the moral law and thus to act against conscience.
And so religious liberty remains front and center. The Church must have the freedom to refuse to cooperate in any way in making these “services” available. It comes down to this: If we provide the means for another to act against the moral law, we ourselves become morally culpable as well. We simply cannot and will not do that. The doctor simply cannot say, “Well, I will not kill your unborn child but let me send you to Dr. Smith who will." Referral under these conditions is simply wrong.
The best solution is this: restore religious liberty by rescinding the mandate.
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
HHS Takes a Vietnam Turn
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
